top of page

Custom Order
Menu

Thanks for your interest in A Spoon Fulla Sugar!

Below are the flavors and base pricing details for cakes, cupcakes, dessert items. Please complete our Custom Order Inquiry Form to begin your process.

Flavors / Fillings

Year Round
Cake Flavors

White

​

Chocolate

​

Red Velvet

​

Carrot

​

Hummingbird​​*

Icings

White Swiss Meringue Buttercream**

​

Chocolate Swiss Meringue Buttercream**

​

Cream Cheese icing

(Can only be used as a filling, or as an icing on cupcakes)​​​​​

Seasonal
Cake Flavors

Strawberry

(April thru September)

​

Pumpkin

(September Thru December)

​

Marble

(January thru March)​

Cake Fillings

White Chocolate Mousse

Cream Cheese Mousse

Chocolate Mousse

Raspberry Mousse

Oreo Mousse***

Triple Berry Compote

Raspberry Jam

Lemon Curd

Chocolate Ganache

Any of the icings​

Gluten Free
Cake Flavors

Chocolate

​

Red Velvet

​

Carrot

​

Hummingbird​​*

SFS_Utensils_Sky Blue.png

* Hummingbird contains pecans

​

**Buttercream contains egg, dairy

​

***Oreo mousse can be GF upon request; all other mousses are GF

​

We are not a nut free facility. However, we can accommodate nut allergies.

Starting Prices

Custom

Cakes

IMG_1132.HEIC

8-10 Servings starting at $60

15-20 Servings starting at $80

25-30 Servings starting at $100

35+ Servings starting at $140

2-Tier Cakes starting at $180

Hours

Tuesday - Thursday Appointment or Pickup Only

Friday 10am - 4pm

Saturday 10am - 2pm

Sunday - Monday Closed

  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Address

11916 Montgomery Rd

Cincinnati, OH 45249

Contact

bottom of page